Transcript Details
PUBLIC DEFENDER GETS PAID TO PROTECT YOUR RIGHTS, BUT DOES NOT RESPECT THE CONSTITUTION AT ALL!!!!
Summary
Bay Area Transparency posted a YouTube video titled "PUBLIC DEFENDER GETS PAID TO PROTECT YOUR RIGHTS, BUT DOES NOT RESPECT THE CONSTITUTION AT ALL!!!!". The video's title suggests it will criticize a public defender for allegedly not upholding constitutional rights, despite being paid to do so. The creator implies a lack of respect for the Constitution by this public official.
Why it may matter: This video is relevant to the research theme as it directly addresses potential failures of public defenders in upholding constitutional rights, a core concern for civil liberties advocates and First Amendment auditors. It touches upon the accountability of legal professionals tasked with protecting citizens' rights and may highlight perceived shortcomings in the justice system.
Full Transcript
On my time and the way I choose to use my words. >> for the police to get here. I'm not going to engage with you on your time, sir. >> YEAH, YOU ARE. NO, I AM NOT. YOU ARE CLEARLY paid to engage with me on my time. >> As the public defender, right? >> Right, but >> Okay, hold on. Let me Let me go Let me go here. No, you're interrupting me. Hold on. You're interrupting me. No, you wait with your finger up in my and trying to be in my face. So, Because I right now I'm I've been told up to this point Hold Well, no, I'll have you guys write it down. I've been told up to this point that you guys aren't taking the records request. So, don't say I haven't told you what I want. >> What's going on, Bay Fam? It's your boy, Bay Area Transparency. We're back at it once again. For this video, we're in the city or town, I should say, of Rocklin, California. Now, we're going to make this intro very, very short and sweet. We went to the public defender's office, and isn't it funny that those who are paid to defend our constitutional rights, if we get charged with a crime and can't afford a lawyer, are the first ones, sometimes, to want to violate our constitutional rights. Their attitude and take on this situation was absolutely ridiculous. Remember, these videos are always unscripted and posted in chronological order. Don't let the employees say it didn't happen like that. That video's heavily edited, because that's not true. And we always keep the full unedited version in case we have to prove they're lying. Follow us on Facebook, Bay Area Transparency Official. Follow us on Instagram, @bayareatransparency. Subscribe, like, and share, baby. Get these videos out there. We have more coming to you as BAT, and I'm out. That was a nice office. That's cool. No, I'm good for now. I appreciate it. Okay, then one says "No food or drink in the lobby." >> Good afternoon, sir. >> How's it going? >> property. We're asking you to leave now, please. >> Really? It's private property? >> That is correct. >> Oh, who owns it? >> to go. >> Who owns the property? >> You got to go. >> I'm asking who owns the property. >> Well, we're not required to respond to your question, sir. Please leave. >> You got to go. >> Is this the public defender's office? >> That's correct. >> How is it private then? >> You got to go. >> Why is that, sir? >> What did I do? What did I do wrong? >> for you. We can call the police for you. >> Can't we just have a conversation? >> having a conversation. >> So, you're saying I can't ask questions as far as why I'm being told to leave? Like, why am I being kicked out? >> I'm going to call the police now. >> Why am I being kicked out? >> I'm calling the police now. Please leave. This is private property. >> That's interesting. What's your name, sir? >> You got to leave. >> This is crazy. So, why What did I do to be kicked out? >> We're This is private property. We're not authorizing you to film here. Please leave. >> Who owns it? Oh, so it's my camera. >> You can feel free to go to the county and look up the property records and find out who owns the building, sir. >> Oh. Well, I know who at the very least >> leave. >> I know who at the very least leases this office, and it's the public defender's. >> Right? What was your name, sir? >> My name is I'm public defender. >> You're the public defender? >> I'm a public defender. >> Oh, got you. So, why why would you kick me out of the public defender's lobby? I don't get it. >> and we're not authorizing you to film. We have private clients that come in here. Their cases are confidential. Please leave. >> I agree with that. I I agree their cases are confidential. You guys would be doing a good job in protecting the information, I'm sure. >> Please leave. >> So, what is the issue here? >> Before another client comes here. We have other We have clients that are very sensitive. >> Well, I have business to conduct here. >> you don't have business here. >> How do How do you know I don't have business here? How do you know I don't have business here? How do you know I don't >> Because you haven't stated you have business. What is your business? >> I Who's talked to me and asked me anything? Nobody's asked me what my business is. >> You're not You're now you're not responding to me. Please leave or ask or tell me what your business is. >> Well, yeah, I can tell you what my business is. I'm here to get some stuff. Well, you want me to answer or you just going to interrupt? >> Go ahead, man. Go ahead. I'm waiting. >> Okay. Okay. On my time and the way I choose to use my words, the way I the way I formulate my sentences. YEAH, YOU ARE. NO, I'M NOT. YOU'RE CLEARLY PAID TO engage with me on my time. >> Or tell me what you want right now, please. >> Why do you think you don't have to >> Please tell me what you want. >> on my time. You're literally paid for that. >> You are literally not telling me what you want. You just keep saying the same thing over and over. >> I I was trying to, but you keep interrupting me and you're being pushy and rude and excuse me, unprofessional. Try a little professionalism in your life. It'll go a long way. You know what I mean? So, again, I'm here to get some stuff, right? One of those things is these pictures that I'm taking and video. And another thing is some other stuff that I'm going to request from you guys, but I'm not there yet. Right now, I'm still on pictures and video. See what I'm saying? >> Why would you think that that's something we have to provide you? >> What What What >> Pictures and video. >> Yeah, come on. We're done. >> You're not providing me anything. I'm taking it and that's it. >> I've asked you to leave. >> And I've told you basically, no. No. Screw off. Take care. Wow, what what a man. I mean, unprofessional. Just came out out of nowhere. And what's your name? Alfie? He looks like an Alfie to me. I don't know from Elf. Or not Elf. What was that dude's name? The Alf. There you go. Alf. >> What are you doing? >> Oh, right now I'm just taking video. How you doing? >> I'm doing good. >> Awesome. >> Why are you in here taking video? >> Uh well, I mean, that was a good question that probably the other guy should ask. What's your name, sir? >> None of your business. >> My >> Your client? >> I think it's my business. Yeah, I think everybody from the public is clients. That's who you guys serve, right? >> probably >> private law firm. It's a law firm. >> It's a private law firm? >> Contracted with the county. >> The public defender is a private law firm? So, I asked quite He asked that and then runs away. The public defender is a private law firm contracted through the county. No, this is not a private law firm. It is a public defender's office. Now, if they were to come out and say, "Look, we are um not the the public defender or something of that nature." Yeah, I need some help there, uh cuddle buddy. Sweet cheeks. I could use some help, babe. Okay. So, again, I need some help here. Need some assistance out here. AGAIN, I'M NOT YELLING, just trying to make sure they can hear me through the glass. So, at this point, I'm trying to go move on to phase two and request the records that I need. They are absolutely refusing me to request my records. And um you know, it's not cool. I need some help, please. Excuse me. Some lady just walked by. I need some help, please. >> What do you need? >> I need to request some stuff from you guys. >> Okay. Like what? You can't film me, though. >> Well, I'm not going to yell at you through glass, so I need to request some stuff. If you could come take my request, that would be awesome. >> How's it going? >> All right. >> Can we talk to anybody here? >> Yeah, they came out, but they're I've been trying to get some stuff, but they ain't uh >> You want >> They ain't helping, so. >> What are you trying to get the accomplish? I'll talk to them about it. >> Okay. You'll talk Have they talked to you? Are they willing to talk to you or Well, they they need to be, but they haven't. I guess they're waiting on you. I don't know how you force somebody to talk to you. Well, we'll find out, I guess. Well, same thing. When we need help, you guys come, right? Same thing with them. Uh can I get your name, sir? >> Sure. Deputy Williams. >> And do you have a personnel number, badge number, ID number? >> 151 >> 151 Williams. Got you. All right. I just heard the cop say something about the usual things and something else. I don't We will Yeah, we'll get their body cam, so see everything that's said there. Um they've been making me actually have my lawyer get that stuff instead of just going over there, so Yeah, they're just confused. They don't know what to do with you, like if to help you, so Well, they come listen to what I need for help. Are you Is there a particular person? No. Mhm. So, it could just be the clerk, or it could be an attorney, or it could be Yeah, I mean, they came out. I literally tried to tell them what I was doing, and they went immediately to leave or we're calling the cops. This is private property. Leave, we're calling the cops. Leave, we're calling the cops. Wouldn't listen, wouldn't answer the questions, just acted like complete And uh now we're here. So, uh can I get your name and badge number, by the way? >> Yeah, it's Gore. >> And badge number? >> Yes, nine. So, yeah. So, yeah, they're just they We're trying to figure out like how to make you happy, make them happy, so I just don't know what >> to do their job. Come come take the info that I need to get. >> First, you know what building you're in? I'm guessing you do, but do you know what office this is? >> I'm in Nevada, and this is um what is it? Like Reno, right? >> No. No, do you know what office this is? Like what >> It's the public defender. >> Okay. I'm just making sure you that you're in the right place, so >> I'm I'm I'm where I'm supposed to be at. Yep, for sure. >> Okay. And but you don't have a particular person that you're here to talk to. >> No, I never I never was. I didn't ask to talk to anybody particular. I just kept asking for assistance. >> Yeah, the uh the first lady that came to the window or was at the window when you walked in? Maybe? >> Mhm. >> Yeah, so she tried to help you. >> Well, I mean, I guess you could say you could say that. She said, "Hi, can I help you?" I said, "Not just yet. I'll let you guys know." So, that's responding, right? It's I always find it funny how they lie. >> No, well, >> You know what I mean? >> No, they're just saying that you that you didn't say what you wanted like help with. So, you like she said you kind of got silent or whatever and didn't really wouldn't say anything. >> So, that it it it's not true. I just said, "Not right now. I'll let you know when I need help." She said, "Okay." and walked away. Right? So, there wasn't a long interaction there. Then a couple attorneys came out and said, "Leave." And that was it. And I said, "Why? Why do I have to leave?" This is private property, leave. We don't We're not We don't have to We're not obliged to answer your questions. >> Good for her. Just a discussion. >> They just need to come out and do their job like they're supposed to. And that's it. >> If I can relay what job you want them to do. >> Uh well, I need to request some stuff, but yeah, it's it's I can't do it through you and really I I don't even want to talk to >> mean, just just to give a general you don't have to get specific. I'm not asking for anything specific. >> Just tell them I'm going to request some records. I have records and some other stuff to request. >> Okay. Do they know what records to take out? >> when Again, like the the extent of our interaction was, "Do you need any help?" "Not just yet. I'll let you know." And then guys coming out saying, "Leave. We're calling the cops. Leave. We're calling the cops." and then leaving in the room and that's it. That's my interaction. So, they don't know anything because they haven't even tried to do their job or be professional in the least bit, right? >> Got you, but they they don't know Do they know like who you are like what your name is? I'm not asking for it, but do they know? >> No, again, that was the extent of our interaction. >> don't even know like what records you're looking for. >> they just said, "We don't like your camera. get out of here. >> Okay. >> How was it? >> Yeah, I liked it. I don't The one thing that I got from them, which I could well I have 100% confirm, but this isn't like county owned property, it's a private law firm. >> Oh, that doesn't This isn't a private law firm, it's the public defender's office. >> privately owned. It's not owned by the county, I guess. >> So, the building might be privately owned? >> Yes, that's what I'm saying. >> But when the private owner decides to lease this building to the county, >> Yeah. >> they open this up to the public and 602 Os clear, anything that's uh you know, open to the public. >> just telling you just make sure you know that. >> I I They said it. I don't believe that it's true, but it doesn't matter. It doesn't change um anything as far as my rights go in being here, so. >> No, okay. Never said anything about that, but if ultimately if they uh >> Well, that's why they were saying it. That's why I'm mentioning it. >> Okay. So, ultimately if they don't want to help you and then if Has any other customers come through here or anything? >> Not that I Not that I've seen. >> Okay. Let me uh talk to them and see if we can try to uh >> Well, they they have to help, but yeah. >> I I There's a difference. I can't make anybody do anything that they don't want to do. >> you you can't, but we can, right? I I document them not helping and then they get in trouble when we file complaints, you know, so. Real simple. >> Yeah. So. Can I get your name and badge number, sir? >> Me? >> Yep. >> Yeah, Deputy Santiago, badge number 138. >> 138, thank you. Okay. >> Quick question. I don't I don't know what to call you, but do you do you think this is Nevada? Like the state of >> Aren't we in Nevada? Yeah, we're in Reno, Nevada. >> No, no, we're >> Or is it it's it's Arizona then, right? Tucson? >> It's Plaster County, California. >> Oh, no, this ain't California. >> You >> Complete Completely lying. >> you it's California? >> Come again? >> I'm a supervising attorney. How can I help you? >> Awesome. So, um who I need the names of the other gentlemen that were out here earlier. >> So, do you have a question that brings you here today? >> Well, that was one of the questions. That's the first question. >> Oh, you really did? I thought he was just joking. Come again? >> Your question is who works here? >> I I can't hear you cuz they're talking. >> I'm I'm sorry. >> No, you're good. >> We're We're just quiet. We're just discussing what's going on. >> Cool. >> So. I tried to tell him. >> Okay. Real quick, sir. You know you're in Placer County, right? He was just telling me that. That's what >> No, man. It's Reno. We're in Reno or Tucson, one or the other. >> Are you all right, dude? You're in California. I'm just making sure. I don't know if you're joking or seriously saying that or >> I've never been to California in my life. >> But you are currently in California, just letting you know. >> Really? >> Sir, are you Are you joking? You've got to be joking, right? I mean >> California >> Right? >> peace officers. >> I'm giving I'm giving you guys a hard time. I I I know where I'm at. >> Okay. All right. Thank god. All right. That's All right. >> Fair enough. >> All right. Go ahead. >> Okay. Back to you here. So, again, I need the names of the gentlemen that were just out here. >> So >> So, in order to do what I need to do >> I'm not giving you the names of the people who talked to you earlier. That's up to them. But you came here for a reason, and so I'm >> Well, it's it's not up to them. Yeah, you guys are It's part of your policy to identify your guys yourself when you're dealing with members of the public. >> It's not. We're a private law firm under subcontract of the county. >> For the public defender's office, right? So, when I need to come get public records, which is exactly what I'm going to do. Yeah, and the public records act works with you with you guys being the public defender, I can get the information from the public defender's office. >> So, I'm sorry you're confused about that, sir, but it This is a private law firm. Cochran & Associates is under contract to Placer County. >> As the public defender, right? >> Right, but >> Okay. Hold on. Let me Let me go Let me go here. No, you're interrupting me. Hold on. You're interrupting me. No, you wait with your finger up in my and trying to be in my face. So There It doesn't matter if you're a public entity. The bottom line is you do business with the county as that you guys are the public defender, right? >> sub contract office. >> Right. And so with that being said, I can get and request the records through the Public Records Act that you guys do business with the county. >> I'm sorry, no. >> What do you want? What do you want from us? >> Well, I'm going to get a bunch of information. So, it's one of the things is those guys names and the guy who took the picture their picture, so. >> giving you our employees names. >> Oh, I'll get it. I mean, it doesn't matter whether you try to give it >> anything else or is there >> I I need to do a public records request or give me the information. If you're saying we don't do it here, which is completely contrary to the law, then tell me where we do it at. >> So, if you want public records acts from Placer County, you got to go to Placer >> I want it from the Public Defender's Office. >> is Cocklin & Associates sub contract Public Defender's Office. >> So, you guys are the Public Defender's Office, right? >> do public records act requests. >> Are you guys the Public Defender's Office? >> do public defender services. >> Okay. >> That's it. >> Which means you guys are the public defender. You guys are literally listed under this address and on the county website as the public defender. >> Okay, but there's a reason we don't have a website on the county website because we're not a county entity. We're a private firm, sir. >> Right, but your records pertaining I'm trying to tell you, but you keep interrupting cuz you're angry. So, your records pertaining to the charges for the county, the names of the people who are taking cases for the county, and other public records are requested through the Public Defender's Office. You guys took that on when you chose to take on being the public defender, right? And that's just the way the law works. So, I'm trying to do a records request to get that information from you guys. If you're saying I don't get it from you Who do you answer to then to get it from them? >> You want a records request of what? >> Public records. >> Of what? >> Uh it's like 30 things. I'm not going to just ramble it all off for you to just >> us one example? >> What? >> Can you give us one example cuz we don't >> They're just public records pertaining to your guys' job as the public defender. >> Public records as to what we do? >> Ma'am, it's all it's a bunch of different public records pertaining to your job as the public defender, right? It's going to be in if if you guys say you're not the public defender, which you are, it's going to be invoices, what's being charged, it's going to be names, it's going to be records of employees who are doing the public defender's work. Yeah, all kind of stuff. >> Uh did you say invoices? >> Come again? >> Did you say invoices? >> Yeah. >> You want invoices? >> Well, if you're privately charging the the county, then you're invoicing them, right? >> I don't know. Actually, I don't know. >> I Well, I know as a fact that you're not. Because you guys are literally just contracted paid as the public defender. Whether it's somebody's a I know. So so there is no That's my whole point is if you So for instance, if you were a private entity, right? Like you say you are and I was your client, you would send me an invoice to pay the bill, right? >> it doesn't >> How how how would you guys get me to pay a bill? >> We get paid by the county. We don't send invoices to people. >> That's my point. But if you if you were a private law firm, you would send me a bill. If I hired you and said, "Hey, I want to hire you." you would send me a bill. That's how every lawyer does it. >> No. >> You guys don't do that. Why? Because you're the public defender, right? >> Correct. >> Exactly. So how do I get that financial information besides request it from the public defender? There's a part of government code 6250 that says I have to request it from the record holding agency, right? Since these records are generated by you guys, you're the record holding agency. I cannot go somewhere else in the county and request it because it has to be through you guys. So you're just wrong. Don't know what you're talking about. >> can be wrong. I don't know but what are you asking for? >> When you guys are ready to take the records request, I I gladly tell you what I'm asking for, but right now we're at this point where we're on some weird stuff and are just saying Yeah, I know you guys are. It's really weird. >> uh ask, do you guys have like any Have you ever had anybody request public records before? >> have. >> Do you have a form for that? I know the county does, but What's that? So So you've never like provided like a >> We have researched the law. We've discussed it with the county. We are under no obligation because we're a private firm. >> Okay. So what I was just asking to help out is you guys have never received a or you've received a request, but you've never given out You don't have a form or a procedure for that. Okay. Um I know like the courts It's like public information if you view those. >> But the courts can't give me public defender documents. >> No, that's all I I Like you said, we don't know exactly what info you're after, but I know it's like public facing like the portal you can go figure out like what defendant is assigned to what public defender. >> No, I get that. But if you got what I was asking them, okay, look, if you're saying if you're going to deny my public records request and say you're not going to give it to me, then who do you guys answer to in the county? Where do I go with that? At that point they need to give me that information, which they can't because they don't. They're the They're the public defender. >> So what I was going to get to is like the sheriff's office we take public records requests and process our own. The county does have their own procedure, so I was going to actually look that up. I had know I've seen that before. Those are the two that I've seen for the county. >> Well, I know where to do it. It's just a shame that they don't know where to do it. I know what the law says. I know that the public defender's office is where I have to go. Now if the onus is on them to send that somewhere, they they're supposed to do that. >> Okay. >> And that's written in the law. It's not for me to do that. I go to the public defender's office. >> Has it worked in other counties? Like public defenders have helped you with that or just curious. >> I I I mean I get records all the time. >> From the public defender? That's what I'm asking. Your experience with it. You You seem more experienced with it than like >> Yeah, for sure. They are the public defender. >> Yeah. >> They keep trying to use this loophole, no, we're just a private entity who's contracted through the county to be the public defender. Okay, >> Which I don't know if that's the case for every county in California or does or is it different? >> No, actually most counties have an actual county >> Like they're county they're county employees. Okay. >> Um ours is subcontract uh Trying to think. >> Okay. >> Sacramento's public, El Dorado's public, Yolo's public. Um >> Okay. So maybe that's the difference here, but I'm just trying to figure out they Have you done a local You know that we're not in you're in California not in Arizona, but have you done one around here? >> Uh well, I'm trying to do one here, but it >> No, have you done one like in an adjoining county I guess is what I'm asking. Like have you done a Sac County or Yolo? >> Well, I don't know. Yeah, I don't want to answer any of that information. >> we're just trying to figure out how to the I'm trying to figure out the solution here for you. So if it >> Well, the the solution's simple. They they can we can I can file a complaint and make sure that if they are a private entity contracted through the the county, um we can make sure that they lose that contract because of the way they're acting or they can take the records request. It's real simple, but I can let you know when I put out this news story, we will come after your ass legally. >> Okay. Yeah, can I go and look on the county website and see if you can do it that way cuz I know that Placer County takes record >> I'm in person. Yeah, I'm doing it in person. >> Yeah, but I'm just saying if they're not going to help you here, I'm trying to send you somewhere else. >> it out after that. They just need to make the the if they're going to make that decision, cool. I'm just going to hold them accountable. >> Okay. So yeah, you're saying you don't do it. I think that's the decision, right? >> Yeah. We're going to we're going to hold you guys accountable. >> Okay. >> But and you want to look it up on your own cuz I I know I've seen the county website. >> Oh, I got it. I I know I'm in the right spot. It's it's it's not a question to me. It's a question to them. That's why they have public defender up. I don't see their private name up, right? They are Do you guys take private clients? >> No. >> So they only do the public defender. See what I'm saying? They are the public defender. >> Yeah, I mean they're they're not going to help you. >> they're just mad and grumpy that that recording and and whatever other reason, and so they're trying to be as stubborn as possible. I promise you you will be held accountable. >> We want to know what you want. You haven't told us >> Ma'am, do you have a pen and paper so I can tell you what I want? Okay, cool. Because right now I'm I've been told up to this point Well, no, I'll have you guys write it down. I've been told up to this point that you guys aren't taking the records request. So don't say I haven't told you what I want. You guys have refused in particular this young lady here. >> what you want in your records request. >> What was that? >> So go ahead and write it down. >> Oh, I'll have you guys write it. >> No, you write it. It's your >> Well, it's part of the code, written or verbal. I'm giving it verbally. >> Okay. >> But is it a long list? You said it's like 30 things. You know, typically I'm sure you've done it before. Sounds like you're experienced with it, but like you can't just make the request and get the record right then, you know. >> No, no, they have 10 days to Yeah, yeah, yeah, they have they have 10 days to respond. >> Okay. I'm just making sure you didn't have any misunderstanding >> Yeah, I'm just I'm I'm going to give it verbally and and I don't have to give a reason why I'm giving it verbally. >> Only because you're asking I'm going to maintain that we do not have to respond to a public records act request. >> Well, that's what you think. Like I said, I'll hold you guys accountable if you don't. I'll just get an official response and you'll be held accountable. >> That's fine. Do what you got to do. >> Oh, we will. Trust me. You're not the first. >> Okay. >> All right, I'd like your full name. >> Uh my full name Next >> Huh? >> Next >> Your salary? >> My salary >> A copy of your last two most recent paychecks stubs from the county. >> They're not from the county. >> County pays you somehow. We'll put pay stubs or or invoices. Um I'll take your county issued email address. >> There is no county issued email address. We have a private email. >> Okay, cool. I will take um the last three invoices that the county has charged for this uh property. >> County has charged for >> This property. This address. >> For for rent? For lease? >> Correct. Yeah, for the lease for this address. >> That the county has charged? This isn't county building. It's a private building. >> Right. Well, okay, that the county has been charged. Excuse me. I will also take >> County? >> Huh? >> County hasn't been charged for this lease. The county is under We're under contract. We give a blanket number. And we get that number. >> Okay, cool. So, I will then then we can scratch that one off and I'll request the last three invoices that this company has sent the county to be the public defender. >> any of that. >> That's crazy. They don't take private clients or anything. They I will take the last three invoices that you have sent for being the public defender's office. >> I sent to who? >> The county. That's who you'd send it to, right? >> That I send to the county for being the public defender's office? >> Mhm. Like the contract. Like what what the cost of the contract is, basically. >> She knows what I mean. >> Just clarify. I just kind of reworded it. >> I'm just writing down what you said, sir. >> All right. I will take the employees names who came out and spoke to me, the two gentlemen who told me they were calling the cops simply because I have a camera. >> And they worded that way? >> Simply? >> Yeah. >> Simply for >> Yeah, literally. I said, "What what did I do to be kicked out of here?" They said, "You have a camera and we don't like it." Straight up. Funny they're lawyers who are getting paid by us to protect our constitutional rights, yet they clearly don't like our constitutional rights. Funny how that works, huh? Um I'll take the uh pictures that the uh individuals come and came and out and took of me. I don't know who they are. They are on my camera, so we'll When we put that out, you'll see them. When they did that, they made a public record taking that as a public defender's office. So. >> You want something to introduce yourself? You want me to give this to him? >> Yeah. >> I'll take her I'll take the ladies' and gentlemen's full names who are standing next to you. >> Yeah, my name is public defender. And we're not a government agency. You'll see that there's case law that says that we don't have any obligation or the ability to give you public records information. There's a >> Well, I'll look I I disagree. So, you guys are the public defender. Whether you're contracted or not, you don't take private clients. And you guys it it Under your contract as the public defender, you guys kind of took that that contract. Or like I asked the lady then, who do you answer to? Tell me where to go. You said you're the public defender of Placer County. >> It's on the paper. >> You're the public defender of Placer County. Are you elected or appointed? >> I'm not going to discuss it with you. >> I'm not going to discuss it with you is what he says. That's hilarious. Um >> Instructions are on the >> No, there is Yeah, I don't know what this >> was, but that might help, I don't know. >> Oh, yeah, that actually type of request for public records. >> Yeah, I don't know. I haven't read it, but maybe that will guide you to the right spot. >> I'll I'll look at it when I leave. >> That guides you to how you do this. We're having a problem providing records if you're a client of ours. >> Well, you guys clearly do. Everybody's a client. You're paid by the public. >> No, no, no. >> We are all clients. >> No, you're not. >> Yeah, we pay your salary, babe. You're You're We're all clients. If we need something, we have questions, you guys just be professional and answer them and help them. Don't have guys come out and say, "Get out of here. We don't like your First Amendment right. You have to leave." That's crazy. >> your If you have a public records act request, the address you have written is on the paper. If you're a client of ours, we can discuss giving you your file. >> Okay, and I I did Well, my file wouldn't be public, right? It's not It's not public records. >> It's not a client. If Are you a client of ours? >> But what what I am trying to do is do the records request. The onus would be on you as the public defender to send it where it goes. >> Are you a client? >> So, again, um where What's the last thing I requested? >> The last thing that you said was you wanted the names of all of the people standing next to me. >> Okay, and I asked for the guys that came out. Um I asked for the lease. So, any any um the lease uh Hmm, how would I request that? I want to get the contract that your office has through the county to be the public defender. >> You can make a public records act request and we >> That's what exactly what I'm doing right now. >> Well, you're not doing it the right way. >> I I think I am. I disagree with you. >> Thinking you're one thing and being correct is different. >> Okay. Well, hey, thanks for your opinion. >> So, this is happening now. >> Well, yeah, we have no further business. >> So, we're going to stop this now. >> Thank you. >> Okay. So, you're So, you're refusing the records request? >> Yeah, we we received your oral records request. >> No, I'm not done with it. Are you refusing it? Cuz I'm not done. >> Yeah, we're we're refusing it. >> Oh, you're refusing it? Okay, cool. Make sure you have something to me in writing that says that. I'll be back in 10 days to pick it up. >> Yeah, that's actually this might I mean >> I'll I'll I'll read it. They're just Like I see stuff like this all the time, and they're just they're told that. They don't look into it. They're just They're just wrong. That's why so >> It does have some case law in here, but I don't know what this one is. It's a 1983 case. That's >> But it's all the time that they put up stuff and says, "No trespassing." And here's the case law, and it's it's all down, right? So, like I'll read it but I don't trust it but what I'm going to do is pick it apart and put it in the video and show everybody how they're wrong and where they're wrong. >> Have you run into a like a situation like this where it's a contracted public defender law firm before? >> All the time. >> sure how many counties are in really in Arkansas. >> is the thing. They're not They They might say what they're doing is it's it's kind of a way to and it's just probably for tax purposes and a way to kind of wash the money. They're saying, "Okay, we'll be the public defender but we're going to have this other entity this LLC that you guys contract so that we can pay things different, right?" And that's what they're doing. I already know what they're doing. Which is I'm giving me more of a reason to dig into them. >> Yeah. >> But when they agreed to be the public defender, they agreed to take everything that comes with it, right? >> Yeah. And the county does business with them so yeah. >> And they don't even You heard them. They don't even um allow private private clients to hire them. The only people they serve here is public defender people. So, they're just They're mad. They're being stubborn. It's typical. I see it all the time. And when I come back >> that have people react differently when they see cameras, you know? >> Yeah. >> I'm sure everybody that's part of it but like >> For me it's more of a reason to just be professional like you were and and and like well >> He left. >> I haven't dealt with too much but >> He was really working in control and I just stopped by and >> Yeah, no. You guys saw the camera. I mean, you're probably pretty professional anyways but you were just immediately professional. It didn't make you act weird, right? >> some people that are Yeah, they didn't really >> Mhm. But we'll teach you >> As you As you I'm sure you've experienced all over the you know, wherever you record that you get different actions different days. >> my first time actually, yeah. So. >> Is your first time recording? >> Yeah, coming out and recording, yeah. >> Oh, I was thinking about the way you were talking about Arizona where you know, I thought you were kind of going all over the place. >> No, no, no. I I I mean, I've got records places and I I usually write. This is the first video one so. Anyways, yeah. >> threw me off when you said your when you said you're in Nevada. I was like, uh-oh. I hope you're like in the right mind. >> when police officers typically ask people like, "Hey, do you know where you're at? Are you okay?" I I A lot of the times they're taking the route of like is this guy a 5150 issue? What do we have here? And so of course I'm just going to with you a little bit cuz I >> I just meant I meant more so like what what office you're at. >> No, I mean >> But that is a good but when you did say that I was like uh-oh. >> I just felt like it was a good opportunity to mess with you a little bit. >> Uh but I was like >> to read this real quick and I'm going to get on up out of here. I'll take your card. I got them doing whatever they needed or they didn't weren't supposed to do so. >> But Placer County I've seen public records requests through the county and then the courts. I mean that's the California Superior Court. So I I just don't know and then >> Yeah, I just can't do this through the court. >> Uh yeah, the court is at state. >> Like if they said, "Look, we are a public defender for Rocklin but the actual public defender is in Roseville and that's who we answer to." Okay, then really what they're supposed to do is forward it to Roseville but at that point okay, you want to be stubborn. I got you on camera saying you're not going to do it. I'll go to Roseville and file. That's fine. Um but I was just trying to >> But the county is all the courts are just county run. The cities don't have their own like defenders and attorneys and whatnot. Like they have their city attorneys but they don't have like the district attorneys or Placer County employees. Public defenders are apparently contracted. >> Yeah, well that's what they were saying. They said The lady was like, "Well, Roseville's public and such and such is public." >> That is what she said yellow except but like cities typically don't have any of their own attorneys like >> No, I know it's a county thing. >> Yeah, it's a county thing. Okay. But in the Transparent California have you been on that website? It's kind of annoying with all the ads that come up now but that has like you know, payroll information. It doesn't give you like paychecks though but it gives you like income and retirement kind of stuff. >> Right, yeah. No, no. I know I know all about that. >> I thought you did but I was just making sure. >> I know how to get most of this stuff. There's just There are a lot of the things that I'm asking for I can't get through those sites, right? And obviously I'm here to do them in person. I'm testing my rights. I'm also seeing how educated they are in our rights, how they're going to react to them. But when I come and they do certain things like take pictures and and whatnot, I need to request those while I'm here. I do them in person. You know what I mean? So. >> All right. >> Anyways, yeah. You guys have a good day, man. I'll be on my way here in a minute. Once you guys leave, I'll be out of here and then >> All right. I'm going to talk to them real quick if they can open the door for me. >> Take your records request. We're going to, you know, tell you you can't be here in this public lobby that's open to the public for public defenders and you're here for public defender stuff. But we're just going to continue on this path and it's it's it's unfortunate. >> sense. No, it's >> Take take care, guys. >> No, it's clear. >> Um Yeah, it's an unfortunate thing. So, at least the the sergeant, the cops did well. Um they knew what they were talking about. They didn't act crazy and get all stupid. Um which a lot of the times, unfortunately, they do, right? So. Ma'am, can you smile for me? Smile. >> You have a YouTube channel? >> Thank you. Not yet. I'm thinking about start I'm starting one with this with this video. >> What is it about? >> Um all kind of stuff. Yep. Going to be about all kind of uh all kind of news um in you know, things. Well, that's what I said. I haven't even started it yet. >> started it yet? But you're going to? >> No, this is going to be the first video, yeah. >> What is the theme? >> Well, like I said, all kind of news related topics. >> Oh, news. I thought you said new. >> News. >> News related topics in the area? Is it local? Going to be local? >> Uh I live here, yeah. >> Are you a client of ours? >> Uh I don't answer those questions. I mean, we're all clients of yours. You're You're paid by public tax dollars. >> be better if if you would identify yourself. >> Why How would you So, what you're saying what I hear you saying is that I will be professional if I know your name and that's crazy. You guys should have just been professional. That's what it is. I'll help you better if you identify yourself. >> I said it would be easier to help you if I knew who you were. >> But you don't need my For what I'm doing here, you don't need my name. >> If you're a client of ours, then you have a file here. >> Yeah, but I don't Again, so if I am a client of yours, that file it is irrelevant in this situation because I'm not getting anything out of that file. I'm I'm I'm trying to get other records from you guys and other things. Huh? >> On other people? >> My employees. I I've asked Are you saw the stuff I was asking for that you guys have now refused? So >> So what was your original intent when you came here because those were all questions based on when you already walked in? >> No, they weren't. Invoices aren't questions based on when I walked in. >> No, invoices. >> Uh There was all kind of There was There was more stuff. But that happened recently, so why it's on my mind, I want to get that out first. >> But that's what prompted you to come here. Was it invoices? >> No, I never said that. >> That's what I'm asking you. >> I know. I'm not going to answer any questions like that. >> Okay. So you you don't want to answer any questions. >> Yeah, I don't have any answers for those questions. >> Okay. So why are you here? Do you know why you're here? >> No, I forgot at this point. >> That's kind of what it seems like. >> Yeah, I have no clue. >> You have no clue? >> No. Where Where am I? >> Wow. Yeah, that is very clever. Ah. >> Yeah. >> long are you going to stand here? >> I don't know. Maybe a while. Maybe not. >> You're interrupting work that we're trying to get done. >> I'm not You guys can feel free to do your job. >> Go about our job with you standing right here when our secretary has private information that she has on her computer. Don't be looking at our stuff. >> Well, it shouldn't I've already I mean, I've taken pictures of everything out here already. >> not be doing that. >> No, I should be. You know why I should be? >> This is private back here. >> Right, so that stuff's private, right? >> Yeah. >> And the stuff on the computer is private? >> It's locked up. >> Okay. And is it but it wasn't when I came here and that's why I got pictures of everything. It should not be out in the open view of the public from the public space. You guys are not protecting our information at all. There's Alfie again. Alfie! SMILE. BIG SMILE. OWEN, CAN I GET SOME ASSISTANCE? >> Uh what would you like assistance with? >> Uh just need a card uh for the public defender's office. Uh like a business card. So we got one person here is professional. Thank you, appreciate it. Cool, that's all I needed. >> All right. >> Wish I had my reading glasses. Is there any information for for anybody here? Like how do I contact somebody here? >> Uh you can call the number. >> Is there an email though? >> Uh >> I I can't send this story through a phone number, see what I'm saying? >> Uh you can send it to uh receptionist at placer public publicdefender.com. >> receptionist at placer public defender. >> Yeah, walk away. >> receptionist at placer public defender's office? All right, thank you, man, appreciate it. Don't listen to her, we'll think you're unprofessional like her. Cool, that's all I needed. So the one professional guy who comes out here and is like, "Oh yeah, no problem, here's a card." And oh, you want to send an email? Do send it to receptionist at placer public defender's office. The one professional guy that would make this office actually look good, the old chunky lady comes out and says, "No." Says we're done, don't talk to him and makes it totally unprofessional again. These people are incapable of being professional and doing their job for us the right way and you are going to get exposed. You got po-po right here. Who do you got coming back? >> I guess they called and said like he's not leaving. I don't know if they close at 3, that's what they told me, but it looks like you're leaving. But you're leaving though. >> They didn't even ask me to leave. >> Yeah, I get I don't know if they were ringing your bell like yeah, I >> Yeah, I was I was getting a card. I rang the bell they said I was ringing the bell. I rang Yeah, I rang the bell and was like hey, can I get a card and the guy came out and gave me a card and I was like is there an email and he gave me an email and they came out and were like no, don't talk to him. The only professional guy here. So >> Was that you the public defender guy or not? >> It was a different guy. Yeah, see he gave me a card and and then I walked out. That's all it was. >> Yeah. Okay. >> I was in there doing a narration he handed me the card and then I bounced. >> Oh, there's no >> no name on it. That's why I had to ask for your name. Yeah. >> That's >> So that's funny but even if I don't leave, I mean I can go stand back in there all day. >> Well, they're saying they close at 3. >> They close at 5. It's on the website. >> I look I was looking at the website after you told me. I didn't find it on the website. On Google it said 5. >> Yeah. >> But on their website I didn't see hours. >> Yeah, they don't close at 3. What they're You know You know I'm sure you know what they're doing. >> That's why I looked it up. >> You know what they're doing. >> All right. >> Take care, man. Thanks for being professional, huh? >> No problem. >> Oh, the sergeant very professional man, that's my opinion. Um he didn't do a bad job at all. Sit inside away. Give me money. Oh, that's where their number is. So that's 1985. And the sergeant is driving the sergeant's driving D1882. 1985 and D1882. That's a good looking dog. >> Okay. All right, lock it up. Have a good one. So, they're closing now? >> Yeah, they close >> Cool, I want to get that on camera. >> They close at 3:00 on Friday, they get >> It's not even 3:00. >> I got to close, I got >> Yeah. Not not really, not when we're paying them. >> No, I know. >> So, check it out ladies and gentlemen, it's not 3:00. It's about 10:00 till and they just came out and closed office, as you can see, look, it's locked. They closed the office. And uh Shut your funky ass up, boy. I don't know what that dude is saying, but he's yelling at me, so as you can see, look, no sound. Let me close my mouth and shake the door so you can hear it. Look, boom boom boom boom, closed. So, they have now locked the door. You can see the lock in there, bing. Um closing locked the door at 10 minutes before they're supposed to. Oh, no, we close at 3:00 on Friday. Oh, is that in the contract? Let's see, cuz I'm I'm curious. Are they supposed to be closing at 3:00? I seriously doubt it. But, now we will uh go ahead and boogie on and we have more information to put out there, you know?